If I was slightly more hip, slightly more quirky, and slightly more in possession of a cupcake pan – I got angry at my silicone one and Goodwilled when we moved – Lavender Moon Cupcakery would be exactly the kind of cupcakery I would want to open if I ever felt like making a drastic career change. (Not that I have a career now or anything, but you know what I mean…)
This Old Town cupcakery is tucked away in a sliver of a row house off of King Street, and while the exterior looks like an obedient member of the Historic District, the interior is anything but. The walls are painted with thick vertical stripes of pink and red, all the furnishings look fresh out of the thrift store (in a good way), and the ceiling is festooned – for lack of a not-quite-so-random word – with cupcake ornaments and mismatching chandeliers. If the Mad Hatter let off the tea, switched over to cupcakes, and moved in with your eccentric aunt, this is where they would party.
Very eccentric. Very original. You get the idea.
The cupcakes are displayed on raised cake plates behind a sheet of framed glass. There was a microscopic menu taped to the front of the case, but as none of the cupcakes are labeled and I almost blind, it wasn’t very helpful. This was annoying while we waited in line, but when it was our turn to order, the woman took the time to point out and explain every flavor to us, which turned out to be very personable and much more informative than reading mystifying names off a menu. (Aka “what happens to me every time I go to Ben & Jerry’s.”) Sister V., Mr. C., and I chose, respectively, the Red Velvet, Peppermint Patty, and a S’mores cupcakes.

The table wasn't that gross in real life. I'm not sure what's going on there...
We elected to sit down and eat there, so our cupcakes were served on paper plates – nothing too exciting. (Although the pink and red paper napkins matched the walls. I love those kind of details!) Cupcakes-to-go, however, are served in adorable Barbie-pink boxes. Oh man…you could sell me pretty much anything if it’s in a cute box. ;)
Sister V.’s Red Velvet cupcake consisted of cream cheese frosting and a strangely-not-red cake. The frosting was tasty, but it was the only thing you could taste. The cake was moist, but nondescript. I’m not even sure what flavor it was. In hindsight, I kind of wonder if they even gave her the wrong flavor. It was the most un-Red Velvet-like cupcake I’ve ever tasted.

Sister V., double-fistin'!
The frosting on my S’mores cupcake was actually a lightly torched meringue – a very pleasant surprise, although I wish they offered a “burnt to a crisp” version cause that’s how I roll. ;) The chocolate cake was dry, but I don’t know if the graham cracker crust sucked the moisture out or if it’d just been sitting around too long. (It was probably around 6 p.m. when we sat down to snack and the cupcakes are displayed ‘open air.’) The chocolate cake in Mr. C’s cupcake was "box mix moist" (i.e. practically perfect), so maybe it was just a fluke. The frosting on his cupcake tasted like peppermint patty concentrate. Holy smokes, no watered-down extract here!
So what did my panel of cupcake tasters decide? (Speaking of cupcake tasters, you people are coming out of the woodwork! ;)
Cupcakery Design - 4 out of 5 Cupcakes
The Cake - 3.5 out of 5 Cupcakes
The Frosting - 4 out of 5 Cupcakes
If not for the inconsistent cake moisture issue, Lavender Moon would be tied for first place with
Alexandria Cupcake in my book! Way to go, Old Town! Cleaning up the cupcake wars. :)